Welcome to Madison Mutual Insurance Company!

We are a local, Upstate New York insurance company that has been committed to quality for well over a century. Our name is derived from our home and place of origin – Madison County, NY.

Madison Mutual is a modern, innovative company with a highly knowledgeable staff. We are proud to offer cutting-edge online quoting and policy servicing to our numerous independent insurance agency partners. And yet, we are still a small, local and friendly company where a real person answers the telephone during business hours. With Madison Mutual, you get the best of both worlds!